Best Mattress Stores in Indianapolis, IN in 2023


A 2017 study by the Better Sleep Council found that a majority of respondents ranked sleep as their #1 health priority, and that 85% agreed with the statement, “a good mattress is key for getting a good night’s sleep.”

If you’re reading this, you probably agree on the importance of a quality mattress, and want to know where to buy a mattress in Indianapolis.

Fortunately, the city has an abundance of options. There are a total of 64 mattress stores in Indianapolis, much higher than usual for a city of its size. In fact, that works out to one mattress store every 5.7 square miles. Some of these have a wide selection, some sell closeouts at steep discounts, and some stores stock specialty mattresses like organic, gel and foam models. A great number of mattress stores carry both furniture and mattresses. Which is right for you?

If you’re wondering where to buy a mattress in Indianapolis, read on. We’ve combed the reviews for mattress shops of every type and presented the best of the best in each area of Indianapolis.

Mattress Stores in Central Indianapolis

In the heart of Indianapolis, you’ll find a large number of commercial buildings, restaurants, boutiques and bars, all packed together in a bustling downtown. What you won’t see a lot of is mattress shops, which tend to take up quite a bit of space for both floor models and inventory.

Bedder Way Murphy Beds

3450 Developers Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46227 Phone: (866) 783-5105

Bedder Way is worth a look. The store sells surprisingly attractive and comfortable Murphy beds and Sealy mattresses to fit. Customers love the functionality, appearance and feel of these hand-crafted, wooden wall beds.

Mattress Stores in North Indianapolis

American Mattress

1410 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46260 Phone: (317) 238-3034

American Mattress Pickwick Commons, a locally owned and operated mattress store in Indianapolis. Customers here consistently report outstanding service from sales associates, who are courteous, knowledgeable, and patient, and work with each customer’s budget, comfort preferences and individual sleep issues to find the right product.

Gordan’s Discount Mattresses and More

7625 Michigan Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46268 Phone: (317) 480-6463

Budget shoppers in North Indiana can head to Mark’s Mattress Outlet in Willow Lake or Gordon’s Discount Mattresses and More. Both of which sell highly affordable mattresses and furniture. In a no-frills, warehouse-style setting.

The Clean Bedroom Organic Mattress Store

1760 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46240 Phone: (317) 548-1818

Customers in search of eco-friendly and natural mattresses and bedding products can find a selection of healthy, green products at The Clean Bedroom. This alternative mattress store store stocks top natural brands like Royal-Pedic, Oyasumi, and Obasan, made from materials like organic cotton, natural Dunlop, Talalay latex, and organic wool.

Mattress Stores in South Indianapolis

A surprising number of mattress shops are clustered around a stretch of US-31 in south Indianapolis that might well be called “Mattress Mile.”

Mattress Superstore

733 Loews Blvd Ste A&B, Greenwood, IN 46142 Phone: (317) 881-3300

Of the many mattress shops in this district, Yelp reviewers give the most stars to Mattress Indianapolis South, a locally owned company. Multiple five-star reviews cite knowledgeable and friendly staff, and the store stocks top name brands like Serta, Tempur-Pedic, and Beautyrest.

Mattress Firm

7701 S U.S Hwy 31, Indianapolis, IN 46227 Phone: (317) 883-8949

Mattress Firm Clearance Center

795 U.S. Hwy 31 N Ste A, Greenwood, IN 46142 Phone: (317) 889-3501

Bob’s Discount Furniture and Mattress Store

7565 S U.S Hwy 31 South, Indianapolis, IN 46227 Phone: (317) 759-2011

The RoomPlace

7609 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46227 Phone: (317) 888-7700

Sleep Number

8707 US 31 South, Indianapolis, IN 46227 Phone: (317) 884-2845

Long’s Mattress

1280 US Highway 31 N, Greenwood, IN 46142 Phone: (317) 859-8540

Mattress Stores in East Indianapolis

American Mattress

4909 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46250 Phone: (317) 594-5900

One of the best-reviewed mattress shops in the eastern area of Indianapolis is American Mattress Indianapolis East, located in the Clearwater Springs Shopping Center. Customers give this store top reviews for well informed and patient sales associates, who are willing to take the time to walk prospective buyers through their options, and who go the extra mile to make sure their mattress delivery is fast and seamless.

Mattress Stores in West Indianapolis

Best Value Mattress Warehouse

5727 W 85th St #1330, Indianapolis, IN 46278 Phone: (317) 228-2337

Up in the West Indianapolis neighborhood of Royalton, shoppers on a budget can score a deal at Best Value Mattress Warehouse. Don’t expect a fancy showroom or sleep consultation here, Mattress Warehouse maintains a simple retail space that’s well-stocked with name-brand mattresses at deep discounts, especially high-end products. Reviewers report that the owner provides knowledgeable and laid-back customer assistance, and works within each shopper’s budget. The store promises discounts of 50-80% off retail, and even throws in a free pillow with every mattress purchase.

Mattress Firm

5630 W 86th St Ste 152, Indianapolis, IN 46278 Phone: (317) 876-3854

Less than a block away, bargain hunters can also explore the deals at Mattress Firm Clearance. Mattress Firm is the nation’s top mattress retail chain, and the store sells all the top name brands in foam, spring, hybrid and adjustable beds. The center is well-stocked with affordable mattresses that have had previous lives as floor models, or which were returned by other customers before the store’s 100-day free-return window.

American Freight Furniture, Mattress, Appliance

5615 W 38th St Unit A, Indianapolis, IN 46254 Phone: (317) 290-9999

A bit further south, American Freight Furniture and Mattress gets great reviews for reasonable prices on name-brand, affordable mattresses and furniture, along with helpful sales staff and fast delivery. This national liquidator offers deep discounts on memory foam, pillow top and euro top mattresses, and stocks reliable brands like Simmons Upholstery, NordicRest and Stewart & Hamilton.

Also check out:
Best Mattress Shops in Indiana

You can also review mattresses online at some of our favorite stores: