Best Mattress Stores in Oklahoma City, OK in 2023

Trying to find some perfect ZZZZZs near Oklahoma City? We’ve done some research to help you find the best new mattress at the lowest prices.

Best Mattress Stores in Oklahoma City, OK

If you’re tossing and turning at night, waking up groggy, or experiencing back pain, it may be time to buy a new mattress.

The National Sleep Foundation recommends replacing the average mattress every 8 years, though most Americans hold onto theirs for 10 years or longer.

In addition to the cost of buying a new model, many of us put off buying a mattress because of the inconvenience- finding a local store, deciding on your budget and comfort preferences, and selecting a model can be a long process.

Fortunately, our list of the best places to buy a mattress in Oklahoma City can help simplify your shopping process. We’ve combed the local listings and reviews for each neighborhood to bring you the top picks in each area of Oklahoma City. Read on, and discover a mattress store that fits your preferences and budget, right in your neighborhood.

Mattress Stores in Central Oklahoma City

Oklahoma Mattress Company

915 NW 4th St, Oklahoma City, OK 73106 Phone: (405) 235-1142

Right in downtown Oklahoma City, you’ll find one of the city’s highest-rated mattress stores, Oklahoma Mattress Company. This locally-owned mattress shop boasts an impressive average Google rating of 5-stars, and has been in business since 1913. The store sells high-quality innerspring, latex, and memory foam mattresses, and also builds custom mattresses to order. Oklahoma Mattress Company offers low-cost delivery and free recycling of old mattresses.

City Mattress

2500 W Lindley Ave, Oklahoma City, OK 73107 Phone: (405) 946-1870

Another centrally-located mattress store is City Mattress. City Mattress is a family-owned store which has been in operation since 1945, and creates their own cotton-filled, tufted, innerspring mattresses right in their Oklahoma City-based factory. In addition to innerspring models, City Mattress carries memory foam and latex models, as well as adjustable beds, toppers and bedding. Shoppers give top reviews to this mattress shop for customer care, including an extended warranty on their mattresses.

The Mattress Store

3609 NW 10th St, Oklahoma City, OK 73107 Phone: (405) 943-4771

The Mattress Store has an impressive 4.7-star average review, and customers praise the store’s responsive and knowledgeable staff, as well as the shop’s reasonable prices.

Mattress Stores in North Oklahoma City

Mathis Sleep Center

3400 W Memorial Rd, Oklahoma City, OK 73120 Phone: (405) 951-1450

Mathis Sleep Center has also earned excellent reviews. This mattress shop offers a wide selection of mattresses, box springs, adjustable power bases, and sleep accessories. Among the popular brands available are Tempur-Pedic, EcoComfort, Lady Americana, Sterns and Foster, and Serta. Mathis Sleep Center offers free delivery, a 1-year comfort guarantee, and a lowest-price guarantee. In addition to mattresses, this local chain also sells including living room furniture, bedroom furniture, dining sets, dining room furniture, and recliners.

Mattress Firm

2220 W Memorial Rd Ste B, Oklahoma City, OK 73134 Phone: (405) 752-1818

Another top-rated mattress store in northern Oklahoma City is Mattress Firm, which has a location in the Quail Springs Marketplace. This large chain is the nation’s #1 mattress retailer, and their Quail Springs location has earned an incredible 5-star rating on both Google and Yelp. Reviewers frequently praise the store’s wide selection and knowledgeable sales associates, who are highly trained in diagnosing sleep preferences and problems, from ideal temperature and firmness for each body, to determining positioning that can improve sleep apnea, insomnia and back pain. Shoppers appreciate the staff’s expertise and no-pressure sales tactics, as well as the store’s sales policies. The store also has a 120-day “sleep happy” guarantee. During this time frame, mattresses may be returned or exchanged, and Mattress Firm will refund the difference if a customer finds the same product offered at a lower price.

Mattress Stores in South Oklahoma City

The Mattress Place

1339 SW 59th St, Oklahoma City, OK 73119 Phone: (405) 900-0405

The Mattress Place carries top brands like Simmons Beautyrest, eco-friendly bamboo mattresses by Cariloha, and economy models like Sierra Sleep by Ashley, as well as Instant Comfort dual-adjustable air mattresses and massaging bed bases.

Mattress Supercenter

2127 W I-240 Service Rd Oklahoma City, OK 73159 (405) 702-9990

Mattress Supercenter also specializes in affordable mattresses, and stocks popular brands such as Serta, Sealy, and Tempurpedic, along with a wide array of pillows, mattress protectors, and bedding. Mattress Supercenter also claims to have the largest selection of adjustable bases in the State of Oklahoma. Customers give positive reviews to the shop’s “sleep experts,” who assess each shopper’s comfort level, spinal alignment and pressure points to guide them to the right model.

Mattress Stores in East Oklahoma City

Shoppers looking to buy a mattress in west Oklahoma City have fewer options that those in other parts of the city.

Payless Mattress

4600 S I-35 Service Rd STE B, Oklahoma City, OK 73129 Phone: (405) 702-0099

One mattress store in the area is Payless Mattress is an excellent destination for those in search of a highly affordable name brand mattress. The store specializes in closeout models, and offers discounts of 50% of the original price on brands like Sealy and Sterns and Foster, high-end options like gel memory foam, as well as beds, bedding and adjustable bases. They do not appear to have a website.

Also check out:
The Best Mattress Stores in Oklahoma

You can also review mattresses online at some of our favorite stores: