10 Best Pillowtop Mattresses

Best Pillowtop Mattress

When it comes to buying a mattress online, you’re faced with such a broad selection that it can be hard to decide which is the best mattress for you. With thousands of options to choose from, how do you even begin?

Narrow down your list by first choosing between the types of mattresses. You’ll need to consider any particular needs, such as mattresses made for back pain, as well as preferences, like whether you like a firmer or softer mattress.

One popular option is the pillowtop mattress, which usually includes a foam layer on top of a body made of coils. Pillowtop mattresses usually offer more support than memory foam or latex mattresses, and they’re softer than innerspring mattresses, so they’re sort of the best of both worlds. 

Even better? Many pillowtop mattresses are quite affordable, making them a great choice for people on a budget.

But once you’ve decided to buy a pillowtop mattress, you still face a crowded marketplace. Which will be the best pillow top mattress for you? 

The Best Pillowtop Mattress of 2019

We’ve reviewed all the options and narrowed it down to our picks for the best pillowtop mattress of the year. Take a look at each one to see which of our favourites might turn out to be your new favourite.

1. Wayfair 11” Plush Basic Premium Foam Mattress

Wayfair 11” Plush Basic Premium Foam Mattress

When you’re looking for the best pillowtop mattress, we suggest you start your search with the Wayfair 11” Plush Basic Premium Foam Mattress. With prices starting at $179.99, it’s one of the most affordable pillowtop mattresses we’ve seen, yet it still comes with a bunch of quality features that will help you get a good night’s sleep. 

This mattress also comes with a convenient 100-night sleep guarantee, which means you can sleep on it for more than three months. If anytime during that period you’re not happy with it, you can return it for a full refund.

The Wayfair 11” Plush Basic Premium Foam Mattress features edge support, which gives you a larger surface to sleep on. Its construction was designed to improve airflow and help you sleep cooler at night. There is also low motion transfer, an essential factor if you’re sleeping next to someone. 

Stats

  • Price: From $179.99
  • Firmness: Plush
  • Materials: foam, cotton
  • Lifespan and warranty: Optional 10-year protection plan
  • Special features: Hypoallergenic, edge support
  • Special offers: Free shipping, 100-night satisfaction guarantee

2. Avocado Green Natural Latex Mattress Topper

Avocado Green Natural Latex Mattress Topper

If you already have a mattress, but you want to turn it into a pillowtop mattress, try the Avocado Green Natural Latex Mattress Topper. This mattress topper is made from high-quality, natural latex, which is known to be extremely supportive. That means it helps keep your spine properly aligned while you sleep, preventing back and neck pain. 

The Avocado Green Natural Latex Mattress Topper comes in two different firmness options: plush or firm. You can also choose the appropriate size to match your current mattress. The topper comes with a 10-year warranty, as well as a 365-night satisfaction guarantee, so you can see if you can actually create your own best pillowtop mattress. 

Stats

  • Price: From $349
  • Firmness: Plush / Firm
  • Materials: Latex, wool, cotton
  • Lifespan and warranty: 10-year warranty
  • Special features: hand-made mattress
  • Special offers: Free shipping, 1-year return policy

3. Brentwood Home Oceano Luxury Hybrid Mattress

Brentwood Home Oceano Luxury Hybrid Mattress

If you’re willing to spend a little more money to get the best pillowtop mattress around, be sure to take a look at the Brentwood Home Oceano Luxury Hybrid Mattress. The mattress comes with a medium-plush firmness level that offers luxurious cushioning while also providing adequate support for your back and shoulders. 

The Brentwood Home Oceano Luxury Hybrid Mattress is made in California using CertiPUR-US® certified and organic materials. It comes with a one-year sleep trial, as well as a 25-year warranty. You also get free domestic shipping in the United States. 

Stats

  • Price: From $995
  • Firmness: Medium-plush
  • Materials: Tencel, wool, foam, coils
  • Lifespan and warranty: 25-year warranty
  • Special features: Responsive comfort system
  • Special offers: 1-year sleep trial

4. Classic Brands Mercer Pillow-Top Cool Gel Memory Foam and Innerspring Hybrid 12″ Mattress

Classic Brands Mercer Pillow-Top Cool Gel Memory Foam and Innerspring Hybrid 12" Mattress

The Classic Brands Mercer Pillow-Top Cool Gel Memory Foam and Innerspring Hybrid 12″ Mattress combines the supportive structure of springs with a layer of gel memory foam on top for comfort. 

Gel memory foam aids breathability to keep you cooler at night. The individually wrapped coils move independently so you won’t notice when your partner rolls over in the night.

The price of the Classic Brands Mercer Pillow Top Cool Gel Memory Foam and Innerspring Hybrid 12” Mattress is competitive, but it’s not the most affordable option you’ll find. The mattress comes with a 100-night sleep trial offer, so you can give it a good test before you make your final decision. 

Stats

  • Price: From $350.58
  • Firmness: Firm
  • Materials: Foam, springs
  • Lifespan and Warranty: n/a
  • Special features: Quilted pillowtop knit cover
  • Special offers: Free shipping, 100-night sleep trial

5. DreamCloud’s Luxury Hybrid Mattress

DreamCloud’s Luxury Hybrid Mattress

Next up is the DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid Mattress. It’s not the most affordable option on our list of the best pillowtop mattresses, but its quality features make up for the higher cost. The mattress features six layers of premium materials that combine to create an ideal balance of support and comfort. 

The DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid Mattress features a luxury firm support system that ensures you get a good night’s sleep. Try it out for 365 days, and if you don’t feel satisfied, you can get a full refund. There is also a lifetime warranty, which isn’t too common among mattresses. 

Stats

  • Price: From $699
  • Firmness: Luxury Firm
  • Materials: Foam, coils
  • Lifespan and Warranty: Lifetime warranty
  • Special features: Quilted euro top
  • Special offers: Free shipping, 365-night trial

6. DreamFoam Bedding Willow 12” Eurotop Latex Mattress

DreamFoam Bedding Willow 12” Eurotop Latex Mattress

The DreamFoam Bedding Willow 12” Eurotop Latex Mattress offers various customization options so you can create the best pillowtop mattress for you. Its special Euro pillowtop section is a three-inch layer of Talalay latex, which offers safe and supportive relief from pressure points. 

The DreamFoam Bedding Willow 12” Eurotop Latex Mattress also features additional layers of latex, as well as reflex foam and high-density base foam. The layers come together to offer an ideal blend of alignment and cushioning. 

Stats

  • Price: From $499
  • Firmness: Soft / medium / firm
  • Materials: Latex, foam
  • Lifespan and warranty: 10-year warranty
  • Special features: CertiPUR-US Certified material
  • Special offers: Free shipping, 120-night trial

7. Mattress America Frost 13-Inch Hybrid Pocket Coil Pillow Top Mattress

Mattress America Frost 13-Inch Hybrid Pocket Coil Pillow Top Mattress

The Mattress America Frost 13-Inch Hybrid Pocket Coil Pillow Top Mattress is one of the more affordable options on our list, with prices that start under $200. Its thickness of 13 inches provides excellent support for your body, without being too hard or too soft. 

The Mattress America Frost 13-Inch Hybrid Pocket Coil Pillow Top Mattress also features a top layer made from gel-infused memory foam. This type of foam not only contours to the shape of your body, but also gives you a more breathable surface, which keeps your body’s temperature lower at night

Stats

  • Price: From $189.99
  • Firmness: Medium
  • Materials: Foam, coils
  • Lifespan and Warranty: n/a
  • Special features: Gel-infused memory foam
  • Special offers: Free shipping, 30-day return policy

8. Modway AMZ-5770-WHI Jenna 10” Queen Innerspring Mattress

Modway AMZ-5770-WHI Jenna 10” Queen Innerspring Mattress

If you’re looking for an affordable innerspring mattress with a pillowtop, you should take a closer look at the Modway AMZ-5770-WHI Jenna 10” Queen Innerspring Mattress. (It does, of course, come in other sizes as well, from Twin to California King.) 

This mattress is 10 inches thick and features both an innerspring system with individually wrapped coils and a responsive foam topper. 

The Modway AMZ-5770-WHI Jenna 10” Queen Innerspring Mattress offers both comfort and support. Its coils help minimize motion transfer in case your partner rolls over in the night, while its foam topper adds cushioning.

Stats

  • Price: From $207.75
  • Firmness: Medium
  • Materials: Coils, foam
  • Lifespan and warranty: 10-year warranty
  • Special features: Motion isolation
  • Special offers: Free shipping, 30-day return policy

9. Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Hybrid

Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Hybrid

When comfort and better sleep are your priority, and you have a larger budget to spend on the very best pillowtop mattress you can find, the Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Hybrid is worth considering. This mattress combines a pocketed coil system with high-quality foam layers for the ultimate sleep experience. 

When you buy the Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Hybrid, you get access to a lifetime warranty, as well as a lifetime comfort guarantee. Nest claims this is the most comfortable mattress on the market, and that guarantee lets you try it for yourself before deciding if you agree. 

Stats

  • Price: From $899
  • Firmness: Plush / Medium / Luxury Firm
  • Materials: Foam, coils
  • Lifespan and Warranty: Lifetime warranty
  • Special features: CertiPUR-US Foam
  • Special offers: Free shipping

10. Olee Sleep 13-Inch Galaxy Hybrid Gel-Infused Memory Foam and Pocket Spring Mattress

Olee Sleep 13-Inch Galaxy Hybrid Gel-Infused Memory Foam and Pocket Spring Mattress

Last up, we have the Olee Sleep 13-Inch Galaxy Hybrid Gel-Infused Memory Foam and Pocket Spring Mattress. If you’re interested in buying the best pillowtop mattress without breaking the bank, this might be an option for you — it starts at just $235. 

This mattress also comes with free shipping, and it comes in a relatively small box, which makes it much easier to get into your home. 

The Olee Sleep 13-Inch Galaxy Hybrid Gel-Infused Memory Foam and Pocket Spring Mattress combine two great sleeping systems into one mattress. On the bottom, you have a quality set of pocketed coils. On top, there’s a pillowtop layer made from gel-infused memory foam, which adds comfort and keeps you cooler during the night. 

Stats

  • Price: From $235
  • Firmness: Medium
  • Materials: Coils, foam
  • Lifespan and warranty: 10-year limited warranty
  • Special features: Boxed packaging
  • Special offers: Free shipping, 30-day return policy

Conclusion

The best pillowtop mattress can help you get better rest at night, while also reducing the pressure on your spine and hips. With so many options to choose from, the search can be overwhelming, but hopefully our breakdown helps you decide on the best pillowtop mattress for you.