Best Mattress Stores in Milwaukee, WI in 2023

Your mattress matters. We spend one third of our lives sleeping, and even more time in bed, reading, watching movies, or relaxing with our loved ones. Your bed is where you rest, relax and recharge.

Cozy bedding and a supportive mattress are key to your comfort, and if you’ve been living with an old or low-quality mattress, you’ll be amazed at the increase in quality of life that a fresh mattress can bring. But buying a mattress, even a basic and affordable mattress, is an investment of time and money.

Before you jump in, you’ll want to find out the best place to buy a mattress in Milwaukee or nearby Wisconsin locations. The good news is that residents of Milwaukee have an abundance of great mattress stores to choose from.

Even better, we’ve taken out the guesswork by compiling the highest-reviewed mattress stores in each area of the city. Read on to find the very best place to buy a mattress in Milwaukee, right in your neighborhood.

Mattress Stores in Central Milwaukee


2929 South 13th Street, Milwaukee, WI 53215 Phone: (414) 272-2470

There are quite a few places to buy a mattress in central Milwaukee, and may have earned high customer reviews. MTOC Mattress is a no-frills budget furniture and mattress store, where customers on a budget can find a highly affordable mattress, along with a bed frame, box spring or full bedroom set.

City Furniture

931 S Cesar E Chavez Dr, Milwaukee, WI 53204 Phone: (414) 645-4500

City Furniture also carries a wide selection of mattresses at their large store, including Tempur-Pedic, BeautyRest, Rest and Renew, Serta, and Kevin Charles. Along with free delivery, City Furniture offers to compensate customers if they find the same product at a lower price within 30 days of purchase, along with a bonus $50 gift card.

Mattress Stores in North Milwaukee

Shoppers in North Milwaukee will find just a few stores selling both mattresses and furniture.

Milwaukee Best Furniture

2670 N Buffum St, Milwaukee, WI 53212 Phone: (414) 265-6000

One such store is Milwaukee Best Furniture, which carries Pillow Top Mattresses and Box Springs by familiar brands such as Corsicana.

Denver Mattress

3550 NM 528 NW, #104b, Albuquerque, NM 87114 Phone: (505) 890-4230

There are quite a few mattress stores in Northern Milwaukee, especially along the interstate. Denver Mattress Company is one well-rated option. This mattress store chain sells top name brands, as well as their own, in-house brand of high-quality, affordable mattresses, called “Doctor’s Choice.” With every mattress purchase, Denver Mattress Company makes a charitable donation.

Sleep Number

3600 NM-528, Albuquerque, NM 87114 Phone: (505) 898-2878

Nearby, national chain mattress store, Sleep Number offers a wide selection and highly personalized options. Sales associates at this mattress store provide free sleep consultations to each customer, assigning each a “sleep number” according to an assessment of their body type, sleep position, comfort preference and any sleep conditions (such as snoring or back pain).

American Freight Furniture, Mattress, Appliance

3804 S 27th St, Milwaukee, WI 53221 Phone: (414) 282-2111

American Home Milwaukee Mattress Store is another well-reviewed option, and offers an attractive one-year mattress “comfort guarantee” exchange policy. This mattress store emphasizes quality mattresses, and stocks Diamond mattress, Sterns and Foster, Tempur-Pedic, and Sealy mattresses.

Mattress Stores in South Milwaukee

Most places to buy a mattress in South Milwaukee also stock furniture.

Ashley HomeStore

4771 S 27th St, Greenfield, WI 53221 Phone: (414) 281-3170

One such store is Ashley Furniture, a popular chain selling quality furniture and mattresses at affordable prices, including foam, gel, innerspring, memory foam, hybrid and wrapped coil models.

American Freight Furniture, Mattress, Appliance

3804 S 27th St, Milwaukee, WI 53221 Phone: (414) 282-2111

American Freight Furniture and Mattress also stocks both furniture and mattresses, and carries brands like Nordic and Simmons, at prices as low as $100. Shoppers here are consistently satisfied with the knowledgeable staff, who are helpful and don’t exert sales pressure.

Penny Mustard Distribution & Clearance Center

6800 Industrial Loop, Greendale, WI 53129 Phone: (414) 433-1500

Locally-owned Penny Mustard Furnishings stocks a large range of mattresses, bedding accessories including bed frames, mattress protectors and Mattress Pads.

Big Lots

5667 S 27th St, Milwaukee, WI 53221 Phone: (414) 281-3550

Those looking for a steal on a new mattress can explore the stock at Big Lots, which has incredible deals on closeout and overstock goods from groceries to clothing, to housewares and mattresses. The inventory turns over rapidly, but those with patience and luck can score a new mattress for up to 80% off the original retail price.

Mattress Stores in East Milwaukee

There are just a few places to buy a mattress in East Milwaukee.

American Freight Appliance, Furniture, Mattress

3203 N Mayfair Rd, Wauwatosa, WI 53222 Phone: (414) 607-9634

One reliable option is American Freight Appliance, Furniture, Mattress, a longstanding department store which stocks standby mattress brands like Sealy, Nature’s Sleep, Beautyrest, and Night Therapy, along with Box Springs & Foundations, Bed Frames, Mattress Pads & Protectors, and Bedding.

Milwaukee Mattress & Furniture, Inc.

423 N 3rd St #3001, Milwaukee, WI 53203 Phone: (414) 271-7335

Milwaukee Mattress & Furniture, Inc. is a locally-owned store selling both furniture and mattresses. The store has manufactured their own line of high-quality and affordable mattresses right in Milwaukee since 1960, including innerspring, memory foam, latex and individually pocketed styles.

Brady Street Futons

1200 E Brady St, Milwaukee, WI 53202 Phone: (414) 277-8088

Those considering a futon as a versatile mattress alternative can check out Brady Street Futons, which stocks a wide variety of durable and stylish futons at all price points.

Mattress Stores in West Milwaukee

Verlo Mattress

6501 W Layton Ave, Greenfield, WI 53220 Phone: (414) 282-4334

In West Milwaukee, customers can pick up an affordable new mattress at Verlo Mattress. Verlo locally manufactures and sells their signature brand of adjustable mattresses. These innovative products can be professionally adjusted for increased firmness or softness over time, and are both durable and versatile. Their spacious showroom also stocks smart sleep monitors and adjustable bases.

Colder’s Furniture, Appliances, and Mattresses

333 S 108th St, West Allis, WI 53214 Phone: (414) 476-1574

Colder’s Furniture, Appliances, and Mattresses has a huge inventory of discounted furniture and mattresses, with reliable and affordable mattress brands like iComfort, Perfect Sleeper, Serta, SertaPedic and Majestic, as well as pillows and bedding, adjustable bases and mattress protectors.

Also check out:
Best Mattress Shops in Wisconsin

You can also review mattresses online at some of our favorite stores: